How to fill open shifts in nursing, in the right order

Fill open nursing shifts in an order that protects your budget and your staff: who to ask first, how to post a shift people see, and how to spread pickups.

The short version

  • Fill open shifts in a fixed order. Your own part timers and PRN staff at straight time first, then the float pool, then incentive shifts, then agency, and holdovers only when everything else has failed.
  • Most open shifts are known weeks ahead. Post them the day the schedule posts, in one place, with the date, hours, role, skills needed and how the shift will be awarded.
  • Track pickups by person. If the same few nurses carry most of the holes, cap them and offer the next shift to whoever has picked up the least.
  • An incentive that staff know about and expect is a nondiscretionary bonus under federal rules, and the Department of Labor says those go into the regular rate used to figure overtime. Ask payroll before you design one.
  • Watch the hours, not just the headcount. A study of hospital staff nurses found error risk rose with overtime, weeks over 40 hours and shifts longer than 12.5 hours.

If you want to know how to fill open shifts in nursing without blowing the budget or wearing out your best people, the answer is an order and a habit. Ask in the same order every time: your own part timers and PRN staff, then the float pool, then incentive shifts, then agency, with holdovers as the true last resort. And post every hole early, in one place, so the people who want hours actually see it.

Most units do the opposite. A hole shows up, someone sends a group text, the same three nurses answer, and the shift gets covered with overtime that nobody planned. It works until those three nurses burn out. This guide covers where open shifts come from, the order to fill them, how to post one, a worked example from a six week schedule, and how to keep pickups fair.

Where your open shifts come from

Before you fill a hole, know which kind it is. They need different fixes.

Kind of holeWhen you find outBest fix
Built into the schedule (vacancies, leave, FTEs below your grid)When the schedule is built, weeks aheadPost it with the schedule and fill it like a normal shift
Approved time off after postingDays to weeks aheadPost it right away, before it becomes a last minute hole
Census higher than the grid planned forThe day before or the same dayFloat pool, on call staff, flexing assignments
Call outsHours aheadA short call list, in the same order every time

The first two rows are where most of your money goes, and they are the easiest to fix, because you know about them early. A unit that fills its built in holes at posting time only has to scramble for call outs. A unit that waits until the week before turns every built in hole into a crisis, and crises get filled with overtime and agency.

If your schedule keeps posting with the same number of holes every period, that is not a filling problem. It is a staffing problem: your FTEs do not match your grid. Our guide to calculating FTEs for a nursing unit shows how to put a number on the gap.

The order to fill them

The order below runs from the cheapest, most familiar option to the most expensive and least familiar one. Write it down so every charge nurse and scheduler uses the same one.

  1. Part timers who want more hours, at straight time. A part time nurse who picks up a shift and stays under her overtime threshold costs you her normal rate. Ask them first, and ask early.
  2. PRN and per diem staff on your unit. They know your unit and your patients. If your PRN agreements require a minimum number of shifts per period, the open shift list is also how they meet it.
  3. The float pool, or a sister unit's staff. Request float pool help for the holes you know about, not only on the morning of. A float pool can only plan around the requests it knows about.
  4. Incentive shifts. This is where full time staff pick up into overtime, usually with a bonus on top. Use incentive pay for the holes that are left after steps one to three, and for the shifts nobody wants, like holiday nights.
  5. Agency or travel staff. For long gaps, a contract can be the right answer. For a single shift, agency is usually your priciest hour and the nurse who knows your unit least.
  6. Holdovers and mandatory overtime. Asking someone to stay four hours past a 12 hour shift is the last resort, not a step. More on why below.

Two things make this order work in real life. First, a step only counts if you finish it before moving on. Posting an incentive on day one because it fills faster teaches staff to wait for the bonus. Second, set a deadline for each step. For example: built in holes go to part timers and PRN staff when the schedule posts, to the float pool after one week, and to incentive slots after two.

How to post an open shift so people see it

An open shift nobody sees stays open. A good posting has six things:

  • Date and hours. "Saturday 11/21, 1900 to 0700."
  • Role and skills. "RN, charge capable" or "RN, CRRT trained." If the shift needs a specific skill, say so up front so you do not have to undo a pickup later.
  • Pay. Straight time, or the incentive amount and the rules for earning it.
  • How it is awarded. First come first served, or the person with the fewest pickups this period, or seniority. Pick one and say it.
  • The deadline. "Awarded Friday at noon." People decide faster when there is a date.
  • Where to sign up. One place. Not a text reply, not a sticky note, not a hallway conversation.

Post all open shifts in the same place, every time, and make that place the schedule itself. When a pickup lives in a text thread, you get the same problems as swaps that live in a text thread: two nurses who both think they have the shift, or none. Our shift swap policy guide covers that failure in detail, and the fix is the same: it is not real until it is on the schedule.

A worked example

Here is a made up unit. The numbers are invented, but the shape will look familiar.

Your 30 bed unit runs 12 hour shifts on a six week schedule. Your grid calls for 6 RNs on nights at a census of 24. After everyone's requested shifts and commitments are on the schedule, you have 18 open RN night shifts across the six weeks. That is 18 × 12 = 216 hours.

You work through the order the day the schedule posts:

StepShifts filledHoursRunning total open
Start18
Part timers at straight time (4 nurses, staying at or under 36 hours a week)67212
PRN staff on the unit4488
Float pool, requested at posting3365
Incentive slots for full timers4481
Agency1120

Steps one to three filled 13 of the 18 shifts, or 156 of the 216 hours, before anyone was offered a bonus. Only 5 shifts, or 60 hours, needed incentive pay or agency.

Now run the same 18 shifts the common way. Nothing is posted until the week before. Part timers already made other plans and the float pool is spoken for. So the holes go straight to incentive pay for full timers. A full time nurse at 36 hours who picks up one 12 hour shift that week lands at 48 hours. Spread 18 shifts across a handful of willing full timers and you have bought most of those 216 hours at overtime rates, plus the bonus, plus a few very tired nurses. How much of each pickup counts as overtime depends on how your hospital counts it; our guide to the 8/80 overtime rule explains the two common ways.

The difference between those two versions is not effort. It is timing and order.

Incentive pay: what to check before you offer it

Incentive shifts work, and that is the problem. Once a unit always posts a bonus, staff learn to wait for it, and the bonus becomes part of the pay.

Set it up so it stays an exception:

  • Only after the earlier steps. Incentive slots open after straight time options have had their turn.
  • Only for certain shifts. Nights, weekends, holidays, or a stretch with a known gap. Not every hole.
  • Written rules. Who qualifies, how much, and what happens if the nurse who took it calls out. Decide ahead of time, for example, whether a nurse who calls out of an incentive shift keeps the incentive for the rest of the period.
  • A review date. Look at the program every quarter and decide whether you still need it.

There is also a pay question that belongs to payroll, not the unit. The Department of Labor says nondiscretionary bonuses are included in the regular rate of pay, and that a bonus is nondiscretionary when employees know about and expect it. Its examples include bonuses announced to employees to induce them to work more efficiently, and attendance bonuses. An incentive you post ahead of time for picking up a shift is something staff know about and expect. So if a nurse earns it in a week she also works overtime, her overtime may need to be figured on a higher rate than her base pay. This is not legal advice. Before you announce a program, ask payroll and HR how they will pay it.

Keep the same five people from carrying every hole

Every unit has them. The nurses who always say yes. They are the reason your holes get filled, and they are the people most at risk of leaving.

Track pickups by person, every schedule period. A simple tally is enough:

NurseExtra shifts this periodHours last two weeks
A584
B472
C148
D036

Then use it:

  • Offer the next shift to the people at the bottom of the list first, at least for the first day a shift is posted.
  • Set a cap. For example, no more than a set number of extra shifts per period without a conversation with you.
  • Check rest, not just hours. ANA's 2026 position statement on nurse fatigue calls for expected work hours of no more than 40 a week, and asks nurses and employers to weigh rest and sleep when offering or accepting work, including on call, voluntary or mandatory overtime.

The research backs that up. A study of hospital staff nurses published in Health Affairs found that the risk of error rose with extended shifts, overtime and work weeks longer than 40 hours, and rose notably on shifts longer than 12.5 hours. That is exactly what a four hour holdover after a 12 hour shift is. It is why holdovers sit at the bottom of the order, and why a nurse with 84 hours in two weeks should not be the first name you call.

When the open shift list, the pickups and the hours sit in one place, this is a lot easier to see. In Adelo Workforce, open shifts, pickups and incentive slots live on the same schedule leaders approve, with live coverage by role, so you can see who has picked up what before you offer the next one. The leaders page shows how it works.

Questions people ask

How do you get nurses to pick up extra shifts?

Post the shifts early, in one place, with the hours, the pay and a clear deadline. Ask part timers and PRN staff first, since many of them want the hours. Use incentive pay for the hard shifts, like holiday nights, rather than for every hole, so staff do not learn to wait for a bonus.

What is an open shift in nursing?

An open shift is a shift your staffing plan needs that has no one on the schedule for it. It can come from a vacancy, approved leave, a call out or a higher census than you planned for. Units usually post open shifts so staff can sign up for them.

How far ahead should open shifts be posted?

As soon as you know about them. Holes that are built into the schedule should post the same day the schedule does. The longer a hole sits unposted, the fewer straight time options are left to fill it.

Is agency staffing bad for patient care?

Not by itself. A good agency or travel nurse who is oriented and supported can do great work. The problem is a unit that relies on agency to fill single shifts, because each new face needs orientation and does not know your routines. For long gaps, a contract nurse is often the right call.

Can a nurse refuse to pick up an open shift?

A voluntary open shift is just that, voluntary. Mandatory overtime and holdovers are a different question. Check your state's rules, any union contract and your HR team before you require anyone to stay.

Sources

  1. Fact Sheet #56C: Bonuses under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), U.S. Department of Labor, nondiscretionary bonuses in the regular rate, and examples including attendance bonuses and bonuses announced to induce employees to work more efficiently.
  2. Addressing Nurse Fatigue to Promote Health, Safety, and Well Being for All, American Nurses Association position statement, effective May 2026, expected work hours of no more than 40 a week and weighing rest when offering or accepting work, including overtime.
  3. The working hours of hospital staff nurses and patient safety, Rogers AE and colleagues, Health Affairs, 2004 (AHRQ PSNet summary), error risk with extended shifts, overtime and weeks over 40 hours, and on shifts longer than 12.5 hours.
Adam DeLeon, critical care nurse leader and founder of Adelo

Adam DeLeon, MBA, BSN, RN, NE-BC, CCRN-CSC

Adam is a board certified critical care nurse leader who manages a large cardiovascular ICU and built Adelo Workforce from the workflows he uses to run it.

“I built Adelo because my own critical care unit deserved one calm place to run the shift. Every workflow in it started as a problem I lived on the floor.”
Adam DeLeon, critical care nurse leader and founder of AdeloAdam DeLeonFounder and critical care nurse leader

See Adelo on your unit.

Twenty minutes with the nurse leader who built it, starting from the thing you most want to fix.

Free for every nurse, tech and secretary. Start a unit free