How to reduce nursing overtime on your unit

How to reduce nursing overtime by finding where it comes from: late charting, holdovers, uneven weeks and thin schedules. Measure it by cause, then fix each.

The short version

  • Overtime on a nursing unit comes from a few places you can name. Staying late to chart, holdovers for call outs, pickups that land a full timer over 40, uneven weeks on the schedule, and education on a day off.
  • Measure it by cause and by person every pay period, not as one number. Overtime hours divided by total worked hours gives you a rate you can track.
  • Under the federal rule each workweek stands on its own. A nurse who works 48 hours one week and 24 the next is owed overtime for the first week, even though the two weeks add up to 72.
  • Time a nurse spends charting after her shift counts as hours worked even if nobody asked her to stay, and the Department of Labor says it has to be paid. The fix is the workload, not a rule against staying late.
  • Cutting overtime is about more than money. Studies of hospital nurses link overtime and weeks over 40 hours with more errors and worse patient safety, and that includes voluntary overtime.

If you want to know how to reduce nursing overtime, start by finding out where yours comes from, because it is almost never one thing. On most units it is a mix of nurses staying late to chart, holdovers for call outs, pickups that push full timers past 40 hours, schedules that put four shifts in one week and two in the next, and classes on days off. Measure each of those separately, fix the biggest one first, and the total comes down without anyone working harder.

The usual advice is to "hire more staff" or "use a float pool." Fine, but that skips the part a manager actually controls this month. This guide covers the five sources of unit overtime, how to measure them, a worked example from one pay period, and a fix for each.

Where nursing overtime actually comes from

Pull your last two pay periods of overtime and sort every hour into one of these buckets. Most units find that two of them carry most of the hours.

SourceWhat it looks likeWho usually controls it
Staying late15 to 60 minutes past shift end, finishing charting, a late admission, a long reportThe workload and the charge nurse
HoldoversA nurse stays 4 hours past a 12 hour shift because the next shift is short after a call outYour call out process and backup plan
Pickups into overtimeA full timer at 36 hours picks up a 12 to fill a hole and lands at 48Your schedule and your fill order
Uneven weeksA full timer is scheduled 4 shifts one week and 2 the nextWhoever builds the schedule
Education and meetingsA required class or staff meeting on a day offYou and your educator

Two of these are hidden in plain sight. Uneven weeks look fine on a two week view because the total is right. Staying late looks like a few minutes here and there, but 30 minutes a shift across a unit adds up fast. Those two are often the cheapest to fix.

The rules that decide what counts as overtime

You do not need to be a payroll expert, but three federal rules explain most of the surprises. This is not legal advice; your HR team and your state or contract rules may add more.

Overtime is figured per workweek. Under the Fair Labor Standards Act, overtime is owed at not less than time and one half the regular rate for hours over 40 in a workweek. The Department of Labor defines a workweek as a fixed and regularly recurring period of 168 hours, seven consecutive 24 hour periods, and says plainly that averaging hours over two or more weeks is not permitted.

That is why uneven weeks cost money. A full time night nurse scheduled for 36 hours a week, 72 hours a pay period, looks fine on paper. If the schedule gives her four shifts in week one and two in week two, she works 48 hours, then 24. Week one has 8 hours of overtime, and week two cannot cancel it out.

Some hospitals use the 8 and 80 system instead, which uses a 14 day period and pays overtime after 8 hours in a day or 80 in the period. Our guide to the 8/80 overtime rule explains how that changes the math. The rest of this guide assumes the 40 hour workweek, which is what most units on 12 hour shifts use.

Work you allow is work you pay for. The Department of Labor's fact sheet on hours worked in health care says employees must be paid for work "suffered or permitted" by the employer, even if the employer does not specifically authorize it. One of its examples is nurses who stay after their shift to finish charting: if that pushes them over 40 hours, they are owed overtime for it. So a rule that says "no staying late without approval" does not make the hours go away. If the work gets done, it gets paid.

Meal breaks only come off if they are really breaks. The same fact sheet says a bona fide meal period, typically 30 minutes or more, is not work time, but only if the employee is completely relieved from duty. If your system deducts 30 minutes automatically, the employer has to make sure nurses actually get the full break. A nurse who eats at the station and answers call lights is working. Those minutes are hours worked, and on a 36 hour week they can be what tips someone over 40.

Required classes are usually work time. Lectures, meetings and training count as hours worked unless all four of these are true: the time is outside regular hours, attendance is voluntary, it is not directly related to the job, and the employee does no productive work during it. Your annual skills day almost never meets all four. Put it on a full timer's day off and you have probably bought overtime.

How to measure your overtime

One overtime number on a finance report tells you that you have a problem, not what it is. Track three things every pay period.

  1. Your overtime rate. Overtime hours divided by total worked hours on the unit. It lets you compare this period to last period even when your census or staff count changed.
  2. Overtime by cause. Use the five buckets above. If your timekeeping system has a reason code for a late punch or a holdover, use it. If not, have the charge nurse write the reason on the assignment sheet when someone stays, and tally it at the end of the period.
  3. Overtime by person. List every nurse with overtime and how many hours. You are looking for two patterns: the few people who carry most of it, and anyone who stays late every shift.

The person view matters more than it looks. Nurses who stay late every single shift are telling you something about their assignments, their documentation habits or their orientation. Nurses who pick up every incentive shift are at risk of burning out. Both need a conversation, and neither shows up in a unit total.

A worked example from one pay period

Here is a made up unit. The numbers are invented, but the shape is common.

Your 30 bed unit runs 12 hour shifts with a census around 24. In one two week pay period, your staff work 4,800 hours in total, and 312 of them are overtime. Your overtime rate is 312 ÷ 4,800 = 6.5 percent.

Sorted by cause:

SourceOvertime hoursShare of overtime
Pickups into overtime to fill holes10835%
Staying late (charting, late admissions, report)9631%
Holdovers after call outs7223%
Education on a day off3612%
Total312100%

(The shares are rounded, so they add to 101.)

Now look closer. The 108 hours of pickups came from 9 shifts filled by full timers who were already at 36 hours. Each one added 12 hours of overtime. Most of those holes were on the schedule the day it posted, so they could have gone to part timers or PRN staff at straight time first.

The 96 hours of staying late came from 192 late punches of about 30 minutes each. When you sort them by shift, most are on day shift, on the days with three or more admissions after 1500.

The 36 hours of education came from a required skills day held on a Tuesday. Twelve full timers who were already at 36 hours that week went for 3 hours each.

Here is what happens if you fix the two easiest ones:

ChangeOvertime hours saved
Offer built in holes to part timers and PRN staff first, at posting (6 of 9 shifts)72
Run the skills day in two sessions and schedule each full timer for one on a scheduled workday, or count it in their 3636
New total312 − 108 = 204

That takes the rate from 6.5 percent to 204 ÷ 4,800 = 4.25 percent, without asking anyone to work less or saying no to a single admission. The late charting and the holdovers are still there, and they are next.

Fixes for each source

Pickups into overtime. Fill holes in a fixed order: part timers who want hours at straight time, then PRN staff, then the float pool, and only then incentive shifts for full timers. Post holes the day the schedule posts, while part timers still have room. Our guide on filling open shifts covers that order in detail. If the same number of holes shows up every period, the real problem is that your FTEs do not match your grid. Calculating FTEs for your unit puts a number on that gap.

Uneven weeks. Before you post, check every full timer's hours week by week, not just per pay period. Under a 40 hour workweek, a 4 then 2 pattern is overtime you built yourself. Fix it with a swap before the schedule goes out. Also check where your workweek starts. A night shift that starts Saturday at 1900 and ends Sunday at 0700 can split across two workweeks if yours turns over at midnight Saturday, so ask payroll how they split it.

Staying late. Do not write a policy against it. The hours still count, and you just teach people to work off the clock, which is worse for everyone. Find out why it happens instead. Common causes on a unit:

  • Admissions stacked at the end of the shift. Ask the charge nurse to spread late admissions, or have the oncoming shift take the ones that arrive in the last hour.
  • Report that runs long. Give report a set structure and a set start time, so the outgoing nurse is not waiting on an oncoming nurse who is still in the break room.
  • Documentation saved for the end. Charting in real time is a habit, and preceptors set it.
  • Breaks that never happen. If nurses are not relieved for meals, the deducted 30 minutes are still being worked. Build break coverage into the assignment.

Holdovers. Most holdovers come from call outs that leave the next shift short. Have a written call out process with a short list in a fixed order: on call staff, PRN staff, the float pool, then a volunteer from the outgoing shift for a partial shift, with a mandatory holdover as the true last resort. Track who gets held over so it never falls on the same people.

Education. Plan required classes as part of the schedule, not on top of it. Put full timers into a session on a scheduled day, or reduce a shift that week to make room for it, and the hours stay inside their 36.

Once you can see overtime by cause and by person each period, the right fix tends to be obvious. In Adelo Workforce, analytics show hours and overtime for the unit next to the one schedule leaders approve, so the overtime report and the schedule behind it are in the same place. The leaders page shows how that works.

Why it matters for patients, not just the budget

Overtime is not only a cost line. A study of more than 11,000 registered nurses in Pennsylvania hospitals, published in the Journal of Safety Research, found that every adverse event and error measure it looked at was significantly related to working more than 40 hours in an average week, with medication errors and needlestick injuries showing the strongest links. It also found that voluntary overtime was related to these outcomes, not just mandatory overtime.

A larger survey of 31,627 nurses in 488 hospitals across 12 European countries, published in Medical Care, found that nurses who worked overtime were more likely to rate patient safety on their unit as poor or failing, and more likely to report care left undone. The authors noted that using overtime to cover staffing shortages may carry extra risk to quality. Both studies relied on what nurses reported themselves and show links, not cause and effect, but they point the same way.

So the nurse who picks up every incentive shift is not a solution. She is a risk you are carrying, for her and for her patients.

Questions people ask

What causes overtime in nursing?

On most units it comes from a handful of places: nurses staying late to finish charting or because of late admissions, holdovers to cover call outs, full timers picking up extra shifts to fill holes, schedules that put more than 40 hours in one week, and required education on days off. Sorting your overtime hours by those causes shows which one to fix first.

Do nurses get overtime after 12 hours?

Under the federal 40 hour workweek rule, overtime is based on hours over 40 in the week, not on the length of one shift. Hospitals that use the 8 and 80 system pay overtime after 8 hours in a day or 80 in a 14 day period. Your state and any union contract may have their own rules, so ask HR how your hospital counts it.

Does charting after your shift count as overtime?

It counts as hours worked. The Department of Labor says employees must be paid for work the employer suffers or permits, even when it was not specifically authorized, and gives nurses charting after their shift as an example. If those hours push someone over 40 in a workweek, they are overtime.

Can you average a nurse's hours over two weeks to avoid overtime?

Not under the standard 40 hour workweek. The Department of Labor says averaging hours over two or more weeks is not permitted, so a 48 hour week is owed overtime even if the next week is 24. Hospitals can use the 8 and 80 system with a 14 day period instead, but it has its own rules and needs an agreement with staff before the work is done.

What is a good overtime rate for a nursing unit?

There is no single standard, and targets vary by hospital and finance team. Track your own rate, overtime hours divided by total worked hours, every pay period, and watch the trend and the causes rather than chasing one number.

Sources

  1. Fact Sheet #23: Overtime Pay Requirements of the FLSA, U.S. Department of Labor, overtime at time and one half for hours over 40 in a workweek, the definition of a workweek, and no averaging over two or more weeks.
  2. Fact Sheet #53: The Health Care Industry and Hours Worked, U.S. Department of Labor, work suffered or permitted, nurses charting after their shift, meal periods and automatic deductions, and when training counts as work time.
  3. Fact Sheet #54: The Health Care Industry and Calculating Overtime Pay, U.S. Department of Labor, the 8 and 80 system for hospitals and the prior agreement it requires.
  4. The Effect of Work Hours on Adverse Events and Errors in Health Care, Olds DM and Clarke SP, Journal of Safety Research, 2010, errors and adverse events linked to weeks over 40 hours, including voluntary overtime, in 11,516 registered nurses.
  5. Nurses' Shift Length and Overtime Working in 12 European Countries, Griffiths P and colleagues, Medical Care, 2014, overtime linked to poor or failing patient safety ratings and care left undone in 31,627 nurses.
Adam DeLeon, critical care nurse leader and founder of Adelo

Adam DeLeon, MBA, BSN, RN, NE-BC, CCRN-CSC

Adam is a board certified critical care nurse leader who manages a large cardiovascular ICU and built Adelo Workforce from the workflows he uses to run it.

This guide explains the rules in general terms. It is not legal advice. For a decision about your own unit, check with your HR or legal team.

“I built Adelo because my own critical care unit deserved one calm place to run the shift. Every workflow in it started as a problem I lived on the floor.”
Adam DeLeon, critical care nurse leader and founder of AdeloAdam DeLeonFounder and critical care nurse leader

See Adelo on your unit.

Twenty minutes with the nurse leader who built it, starting from the thing you most want to fix.

Free for every nurse, tech and secretary. Start a unit free